
One day, 15-year old Ellie Mack was living her ideal life, preparing for exams, in a relationship with a wonderful boy and on her way to the library…and then she was gone. She disappeared without a trail, leaving her family in despair, especially her mother, Laurel. Ellie was her youngest, her golden child that was the light in the home. Her absence seemed to extinguish that light over time, destroying her parents’ marriage and fracturing Laurel’s relationships with just about everyone, including her remaining two children. Then one day, Laurel meets Floyd Dunn, a divorced professor with two daughters, the youngest, Poppy, who stirs something in her she hasn’t felt in years.
I thought I knew what kind of story this would be, one where the investigation into Ellie’s disappearance would be all consuming and the heartbreak and angst of it all would be emotionally draining. This isn’t that kind of book at all. Most of the story is told through Laurel’s point of view, in third-person, so it provides some distance (somewhat) from the pain. It’s quite the work of art to see things through her perspective and experience the contrast of that with the reality of those in her orbit, particularly her daughter Hanna and ex-husband Paul. Ellie’s absence is always in the background, like an invisible third person.
There’s a literary quality to this story, with moments of insight sprinkled throughout, not liberally but when least expected and giving me pause and more profound understanding of these characters and the insidious nature of this kind of loss. As Laurel transformed, so did my clarity of the other characters, like a veil lifting allowing me to see beyond their original frames. This was more than what happened to Ellie and her fate, whodunnit and why. It’s a marvelous exploration of the human condition and the circumstances of her disappearance just made things more interesting. This was a fascinating story and the narrator did an outstanding job of capturing it and well defining most of the characters. I was riveted.
Book Info
- Release Date: April 17, 2018
- Narrator: Helen Duff
- Audio Length: 10 hours, 16 minutes

Great review, Jonetta! Glad you enjoyed! She is favorite author for us!
Thanks, Brenda! She’s definitely a favorite now for me.
This book really moved along so well. It was my first book by Jewell and won’t be my last. Terrific review, Jonetta!
Thanks, Marialyce! I never knew where it was going.
Fantastic review! I loved this one too and that ending was something else!
Thank you, Nicki! Yes, that ending did me in.
Wonderful review, Jonetta! I’ve only read one Jewell book, Watching You, but I own this one and can’t wait to read it. It sounds like one I’ll enjoy, too, for all the reasons you wrote about so well.
Thank you, Jennifer! You’d love this.
Wonderful review, Jonetta! I enjoyed this one too. 😀
Thank you, Darinda! I can’t say I’m surprised that you enjoyed it, too. This is that kind of book.
Wonderful review! If I had time I would go back and read all of her books! She is such an amazing author!💕
Thank you, Berit! I’m trying to go back and read more. I’ve two on my wishlist at the library.
Fantastic review. I thought it would also be about the investigation so good to know it is more of a human drama. I have yet to read this author but I see her a lot.
Thanks, Anne! It’s definitely much more than the investigation. This is my third book by the author and she’s now on my auto read list.
I read my first Lisa Jewell book a couple of months ago and really want to go back and read this one too. It sounds so good.
This is now my third and I’m so glad friends steered me her way, Suzanne.
I actually just got the audio for this, and I’m so excited after this lovely review, Jonetta! 💕
Thank you, Mackenzie! You’re in for a real treat.
Thanks for this review. I saw this one at the library, but wasn’t so sure. I ended up bringing home One-Hit Wonder by the same author – reading it now.
You’re welcome! I got this from the library, too, and it’s been on my shelf for a while. After listening to Watching You, I jumped right into this one.
This was, is, my favorite book by her so far. It did have more of a literary feel than that of a thriller. I loved reading your review and your thoughts on this one!
Thank you, Mackey! I’m not surprised it’s your favorite to date. Mine, too💜
Awesome review!! I’m excited for this one now 🙂
Thanks, Deanna! I believe you’ll love this one.
Wonderful review! I can’t wait to read this one… I’m hoping to read it in March. 🙂
Thank you, Yvo! I hope you do get to it next month.
I was just looking at this book on audible today and wondering about it. I’ve never read Lisa Jewell but keep coming back to this book as I see reviews. You’re review tipped me to get it. Wonderful review, Jonetta! So glad you enjoyed it!
Thank you, Stephanie! I’m so glad you’re going to read this one. I’m now a big fan.
You’re welcome! I bought the audiobook, so now it’s just a matter of getting to it. I didn’t realize that I have over 20 audiobooks that I need to listen to until I just went through them. Kinda crazy…although that is way less than my physical book TBR, so I guess that’s a good thing! I’m looking forward to this one though and am glad to know you’re a big fan! 🙂
I don’t even want to count mine!
Sounds so great. This would be a new-to-me author and narrator. Great review.
Melanie @ Hot Listens & Books of My Heart
Thank you, Melanie!
Wonderful review Jonetta. So glad you enjoyed this one as much as I did.
Thanks, Carla! Nice to know you liked this, too.