Bookish Stuff, Meme

Streaming Sunday – Pieces of Her

Streaming Sunday features TV series or movies adapted from books I’ve read, offered on at least one streaming service and I’ve watched.

The series is based on the book with the same name by Karin Slaughter. It’s about Laura Oliver and her daughter, Andrea (Andy) and how their lives changed in a moment after a violent attack in a diner. That confrontation puts Andy on the run, at Laura’s demand, and an upheaval of the life and mother she thought she knew.

A group of us read the book together before watching the series, as is my preference because rarely can I do the reverse and enjoy the book. I’m used to TV and movie adaptations having differences but here there are major changes that impact the foundation of the story, including significant characterizations. They rattled me and most of those involved in the group read but there were also aspects we liked better.

For example, in the book, Andy comes across as TSTL (Too Stupid to Live) often, making decisions where you’re screaming, “Nooooooo!” and wanting to jump into the pages and stop her. She’s a bit smarter in the TV series though she has her dubious moments.

The one constant, however, is Laura Oliver, portrayed by the fabulous Toni Collette who mirrors the book’s complex character rather brilliantly. I wished I’d had her image in my head while reading the story because she couldn’t be more perfect in translating the opaqueness of the woman. She’s the heart of the story even though it’s Andy’s journey through her mother’s past, trying to make sense of the present and navigate the implications on her future.

I’m not surprised that many gave this series a cool reception as the fundamental plot and characterization changes from the book seriously undermined the crux and central themes of the story. It came across as a bit convoluted and difficult to absorb because the backstory transitions required too much telling rather than effectively weaving together an interesting narrative.

When we started the book, we didn’t realize a sequel was in the works, which was implied at the end of the first season of the series. I’m not sure a second season is in the future as reviews were mediocre at best. But it seemed to be a unanimous opinion that Collette made it worth watching.

This is a case where the book is so much better than the TV series. I had my issues with the book, too (see my review) but thought it compelling. It’s streaming on Netflix and starring Toni Collette and Bella Heathcote.



21 thoughts on “Streaming Sunday – Pieces of Her”

  1. I knew I should have read the book before watching the series. I enjoyed watching it and Toni Collette was great but it didn’t end on the high that I had hoped it would after so much build up. I seem to have forgotten a lot about it already, I didn’t even know about a sequel… maybe I need to watch the ending again 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Excellent review as you always do. I thought I’d have nothing interesting here since I rarely watch tv. But this is a favorite author. I haven’t read this book yet, although I have it, and of course I haven’t watched the show. I would do that order also.

    Anne – Books of My Heart

    Liked by 1 person

  3. My husband and I enjoyed watching the series. It was left open-ended in a way, so we were hoping for a sequel. I haven’t read the book, and probably won’t at this point. I’m like you — it’s easier to read the book first than watch.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. As you know, I gave up on the series after two episodes. Really disappointed. But I don’t really remember much about the book itself either so I guess for me it wasn’t a Slaughter favourite to begin with. Now I’m wondering if Girl, Forgotten will make any sense to me 😳😄

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Eva, our group read of the book was a mixed bag but we watched the series immediately after reading the book and had strong memories of both. We did, however, appreciate that there was a follow up book coming because we had unanswered issues. I think it will all come back to you😏

      Liked by 1 person

  5. My daughter did not read the book, but watched the series. She really enjoyed it, but I have been reluctant to watch as I heard it was so different from the book. Great post, Jo. I am still undecided.


Comment anyone?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s