Historical Mystery

Murder on Fifth Avenue by Victoria Thompson

Murder on Fifth Avenue



I’m reading this series in one of my Goodreads groups and it’s one of our favorites. It’s set in turn-of-the-century (19th) New York City featuring midwife Sarah Brandt and Detective Sergeant Frank Malloy who often find themselves investigating murders together.





When NYPD Detective Sergeant Frank Malloy is summoned by Felix Decker to meet him at his Knickerbocker Club, he’s expecting the worst. So he’s quite surprised when Sarah Brandt’s father, a respected member of New York’s elite society, asks him to investigate the death of one of his friends and fellow club member. Chilton Devries died at the club and what was first thought to be a natural death was determined to be anything but. Decker wants the investigation done discreetly until they determine the killer. His (or her) identity will determine whether that person is brought to justice.

Throughout the series, justice is rarely meted out to the “haves” in the same manner as the “have nots.” This story puts that practice to the test superbly as the murder victim is determined to be everything but a gentleman. His group of detractors/enemies seemed endless and his true reputation was well earned, covered by the veneer of polite society. I loved how the Deckers were slowly exposed to his true nature, having to shift their thinking about the behaviors of their own class and challenging their beliefs. The biggest impact is on Felix Decker as those beliefs are shattered and he has to face the truths of his own daughter’s life choices.

I found the mystery challenging, not so much for the who but the how and where. Sometimes it took Frank and Sarah longer to catch up to what I’d solved but I was just as much in the dark about how everything had evolved. This was a masterfully told story in terms of the underlying themes and messages. And, having all of the Deckers involved in the investigation was just fun. Frank was put to a test by Felix and I’m still not clear as to the kind and the purpose. That’s a perfect setup for the next story. Still loving this series!

Book Info

  • Release Date: May 1, 2012
  • Series: Gaslight Mystery #14
  • Page Numbers: 300

Goodreads | Amazon | Barnes & Noble | Kobo

Join our Goodreads group discussion!

19 thoughts on “Murder on Fifth Avenue by Victoria Thompson”

  1. Whoo hoo – thanks to you, I now have the first book in this series. I had to get it from the UK but it finally arrived. I can’t wait to start! I love your reviews for this one and all of the others in this series Jonetta!

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Wow you’ve read lots of these. In some cases like this or the ones by Anne Perry or the Lady Sherlock ones, I love the intelligence of solving the mysteries but I can’t help wondering then or now, without scientific evidence or credible eye witnesses if the innocent are ever persecuted. I know this is fiction; I worry IRL too. Wonderful review!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks, Anne! We started reading this as a group January 2018. I write the discussion questions so I’ve got to keep up but this is generally one of the first books I read each month.

      At least with these stories, the guilty party is proven beyond a doubt. However, they cover other situations where the corrupt police pin it on anyone to close the case. That was a reality and pretty heartbreaking.


Comment anyone?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s